Nerd Mr Butter
Nonprofit Strategies

Best CRM for nonprofits: 4 options and how to choose yours

Need help getting your donor information organized? Get reviews and pricing details for four top-rated CRMs for nonprofits and learn how they can boost your donor retention rate.

Rachel Mills
May 17, 2023
November 17, 2020

Table of contents

This is some text inside of a div block.

Table of contents

Share this article


Don’t miss out on weekly insights!
150K+ changemakers already subscribed
Success! Check your inbox, good news is on its way 💛
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

How many months ago did you call your major donors? How many of your contacts have up-to-date phone numbers? Which of your supporters are most likely to give to your next fundraising campaign?

Nonprofit organizations have to manage hundreds and thousands of contacts and interactions, from new prospects to lifelong donors and volunteers. Without Customer Relationship Management (CRM) software, staying organized can be a hectic mess of spreadsheets, emails, and notes.

Fortunately, modern nonprofit CRM software offers an easy-to-use database where nonprofits can see all their important contacts in one place. Donor profiles can include names, addresses, donation amounts, donation dates, preferences, and any other detail your organization wants to track. Some CRM platforms go even further, including tools for email marketing, gift predictions, event management, online fundraising, social media integration, and more.

In other words, a CRM is one of the best tools you have for understanding your supporters and building deep and meaningful relationships with them.

But with hundreds of CRMs for nonprofits, it can be tough to find the right one.

We’re here to help! Below, we’ll walk through four top-rated CRMs for nonprofits and how they can boost your donor retention rate. You’ll also learn four things to keep in mind when you’re making the best decision for your nonprofit.

1. Givebutter

Givebutter is the all-in-one fundraising solution that brings together everything changemakers need to raise more—including the world's first free CRM for nonprofits! With unlimited contacts, smooth segmentation, and easy-to-navigate donor management tools, Givebutter's CRM can spare you the headache (and monthly fees!) that come with clunkier platforms.

Plus, all of Givebutter's easy event ticketing features, fundraising pages, and donation forms integrate automatically with your CRM, so you have a record of every contact's donations, registrations, peer-to-peer campaigns, and communications in one neat timeline, right at your fingertips.  

Whether you're brand new to the world of CRMs, or you're looking to switch to a butter—er, better—platform to meet your needs, Givebutter is built to scale with your organization's growth. And, it's easy to try out in just minutes.

Pricing: Free. For real.

2. Bloomerang

Bloomerang is a cloud-based donor management software solution that’s designed specifically for nonprofits. The platform offers cutting edge CRM tools, like an interactive dashboard, donor histories, marketing automation, and in-depth reports. There are also handy, one-of-a-kind features like an “Engagement Meter” and “Generosity Score” that help you identify top prospects faster.

“Cloud-based” means you can update contacts, take care of tasks, and communicate with supporters anywhere you have an internet connection. Another standout element? Unlike many nonprofit CRM solutions, Bloomerang offers multiple free and low-cost plans.

Integrate Bloomerang with hundreds of convenient apps, including Givebutter! In addition to no-stress contact management, your nonprofit gets access to powerful donation pages, events and tickets, and fundraising tools.

Pricing: Bloomerang Lite is free; paid plans start at $19 per month

3. Kindful

truTV trutv snap easy late night snack GIF

Kindful says they’re "built for relationships, not tasks,” and their CRM system reflects that mentality. The clean and user-friendly interface, intuitive features, and ample integrations have helped Kindful top the list of best nonprofit CRMs for several years.

Each plan includes unlimited donation forms and crowdfunding pages, donor lifecycle tracking, and unlimited report templates. There’s no extra charge for extra account users, and it’s easy to set and adjust permissions according to role. You can also take advantage of free phone and email support, which is often a paid feature on other CRM platforms.

Use it to track donor activities and simplify back-office work so you can spend more time engaging with donors. If you need help getting started, Kindful offers transition support for a $199 starting fee.

Pricing: Starts at $100 per month

4. Salesforce

Salesforce is one of the most well-known names in sales and CRM software, and they’ve expanded their reach into the nonprofit sector. Their Nonprofit Cloud is a complex CRM for nonprofits with a lot of functionality, so it’s mostly recommended for large organizations. Users note there is a steep learning curve, but it’s a top pick if you have a high volume of contacts and interactions.

The Nonprofit Cloud unites your fundraising efforts, marketing, leadership, and special programs in one central hub. Set up mobile-friendly forms, automate receipts, and keep your contacts neatly organized. Even better, the 360-degree view of prospects, donors, and volunteers helps you craft a more effective follow-up strategy.

Another benefit to working with Salesforce is that you get access to the Salesforce AppExchange, a powerful business marketplace with hundreds of apps you can use to build your ideal nonprofit management system. Even better, 501(c)(3) and 501(c)(4) nonprofits in the U.S. are eligible for up to 10 free licenses to the Nonprofit Success Pack.

Pricing: 501(c)(3) and 501(c)(4) nonprofits are eligible for free software; other nonprofits should contact Salesforce for a custom quote

How to choose the right CRM for your nonprofit

Now that you’ve got three great CRM options, you’re probably wondering how to narrow down your options. Here’s what you need to consider any time you’re comparison shopping for CRM software:

  • ❗ Your priorities: What is the number one reason you need CRM software? What are your short-term and long-term organizational goals? Define your needs and decide on your must-have features before you start hunting for software so you won’t be tempted by any bells and whistles you don’t need.
  • 👋  Your users: Which team members will use your CRM the most? How much technical expertise do they have? Is there time for several months of training, or do you need to hit the ground running? What does the donor-facing side of the software look like? Consider everyone’s user experience and think about whether your team needs an out-of-the-box solution or has time to learn an advanced system.
  • 💻  Your existing tools: What nonprofit management tools are you already using? How many can you integrate or replace with the CRM system you’re considering? For instance, can the CRM sync with your QuickBooks account? Can you post to all of your social network sites? Take a look at your current digital ecosystem and figure out which programs you need to keep.
  • 💰 Your budget: What is your price range? Generally, the more contacts you need to store, the more expensive your plan will be. Many CRM plans are month-to-month and offer a 10-20% discount if you commit to an annual plan. Remember to account for any add-ons you may need.

Before you sign up for any nonprofit CRM, make sure you take it for a test drive. Most companies offer free demos or free trials so you can get a feel for the platform.

Your CRM and nonprofit fundraising solution in one convenient place

With CRM software, you’ll never miss a chance to thank, engage, or recognize your donors. And with the right fundraising software, you’ll never miss an opportunity to raise money and spread awareness for your cause!

In addition to Givebutter's free CRM for nonprofits, the all-in-one platform comes with all of the user-friendly features you need to fund your mission and make the world a butter place, including:

Did we mention it's free? Create your account today and experience better nonprofit fundraising.

Get started
Set up your peer-to-peer fundraiser for free in just a few minutes →

Share this article


Don’t miss out on weekly insights!
150K+ changemakers already subscribed
Success! Check your inbox, good news is on its way 💛
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Raise funds better, faster, and for free with Givebutter.

Never miss a thing

Stay updated on our latest insights, events, and good news
Success! Check your inbox, good news is on its way 💛
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.